.

All Contents © Copyright 2006, Boston Neighborhood News, Inc.
Community Comment
The News This Week from Dorchester

Revisionist history polluting young minds
February 9, 2006

To the Editor:

These days not too much that is done or said by a 16 year-old causes shock in this reader. I have only to open the daily papers or flip on the evening news and see the escalating violence that plagues our great city's streets to become a bit more jaded and callous to the actions of our youth. While that sense of shock has previously been reserved for the wanton acts of mayhem, it was the comments from the young and obviously intelligent Mr. Holmes which sent shivers down my spine and caused me to toss last weeks Reporter down in utter disbelief.

While the well articulated and well meaning words of Mr. Holmes seemed aimed at the lack of substance and truth in today's public school history curriculum, calling Christopher Columbus a "murderer" and mentally "sick" as well as saying that the Pilgrims were "killers" is utter nonsense and speaks to the degree that revisionist historians have been able to inculcate our public school system with politically correct rubbish and warped pseudo-intellectual drivel.

Sure, we can look back with the luxury of hindsight and say that the courageous explorers of the 15th, 16th, and 17th century were insensitive to the people they encountered and committed atrocities that would make us blanch today, but that is what hindsight allows us in the present, the here and now, to do. While we may not agree with the methods and tactics they used to conquer the new lands and the people inhabiting them, we surely can recognize that they lived in much different times from our own. Times that called for men to hold to their convictions and set out on the voyages of exploration that opened up the New World and its wondrous people, lands and resources to the old.

These men didn't come from a world of "touchy feely" diplomacy. There was no United Nations. No foreign policy think tanks. They came from a world of subjugate or be subjugated, kill or be killed. Even with that, I've not found any scrap of evidence to say that Columbus was a "murderer" who suffered from some form of insanity. Those who followed in the centuries after Columbus may well be categorized as brutalizing conquerors who sought to deepen the coffers of the European powers through subjugation, exploitation and colonization, but then again, for better or worse that was their world.

Evidently, with these young and talented minds like Mr. Holmes being spoon fed such revisionist cow dung, we can all be rest assured that the editorial pages found in the likes of The Globe and The New York Times will not be wanting for far left leaning propagandists in the future. A future I have been given more reason to weep for.

George M. Greene, Harbor View St.

 

 

 

Let Us Know What You Think!

What do you think? Why not write your own letter to the editor?
You can e-mail it to the Reporter newsroom at
letters@dotnews.com. The Reporter will only publish letters that are signed- and include a daytime phone number for verification.

 

Other recent commentaries from our neighbors:

Teach the truth about American history in Mass schools 2.2.06

Dorchester needs health care reform 1.26.06

Legislature does its part to protect witnesses 1.19.06

'Brutal' days followed successful election 1.12.06

Christmas night, outside South Bay... 1.05.06

Logic lacking in Christmas message of Menino, Reporter 12.29.05

Duck the malls or yule feel sorry 12.22.05

Rash of shootings shows it is time to rethink prevention techniques 12.15.05

Mattapan man writes from Iraq 12.8.05

Booth swings and misses in assessment of Ali 12.1.05

Dear, would you pass the Salt Junk? 11.23.05

The Urban Gardener's Thanksgiving Day Schedule 11.17.05

Rome decides that legalisms trump facts in Saint William's case 11.10.05

Lucchino vs. Epstein: Media stew boils over 11.03.05

Hijacking government 10.27.05

Disturbing trends in community policing posture 10.20.05

Houston was a legal freedom fighter 10.13.05

For one Dot voter, 'unfair' dog law holds sway 10.6.05

Clam Point complaints reveal city's inadequate planning 9.29.05

Firefighters 'manipulated truth' in Grove Hall memorial issue 9.22.05

Declaration of dependence 9.15.05

Increasing fairness in Boston Latin School admissions 9.1.05

Art connecting lives right here in Adams Corner 8.25.05

The human eyes of God 8.18.05

City's preservation policies should go further 8.11.05

"I Wonder What Jesus Would Have Done" 8.4.05

Promising Young Nigerian Man's Death a Tragedy for All 7.28.05

Here's to You 7.21.05

Thanks All Around for Spring Triumphs in Field's Corner 7.14.05

A Time to Speak Out about Violence, Prevention 7.7.05

Time to End Complacency and Wage Renewed Campaign against Crime

Questions Remain About Park Fate 6.16.05

The Truth Be Told 6.9.05

Civic Group Did Its Job in Cedar Grove 6.2.05

Wilson the Right President to Lead UMass 5.26.05

John Beresford's Murder Raises Questions for our Community 5.19.05

It Really Burns Him 5.12.05

The Truth about Our 'Fancestors' 5.05.05

Writer Should Have Offered More ID 4.28.05

Drumming Up Support to Restore a Civil War Memorial 4.21.05

Motley Part of the Problem, Not Solution 4.14.05

Essay Winners Reflect on Dorchester Day 4.7.05

In Remembrance of Ricky Dever 3.31.05

Not a Good Day for the Good Guys 3.24.05

Democracy Tolls for Whom? 3.17.05

Bush Budget Puts the Lie to 'Compassion' 3.10.05

Charter Schools Give Boston Public Much-Needed Competition 2.24.05

Ocean Zoning Needed to Protect Off-Shore Waters 2.17.05

DotWell - An Extended View of Health Care 2.03.05

How to Tell If You're Really an Irish Pol 1.27.05

You Gotta Have Friends 1.13.05

When Never Means Maybe 1.06.05

Putting the Hurt over Merged Parish on Hold for Holidays 12.16.04

Choir Article Was One-Sided 12.09.04

License to Ill 12.02.04

Article Failed to Give Balanced Development Picture 11.25.04

Romney Gets Out-Hustled on Homeland Security Issues 11.18.04

Being John Kerry 11.11.04

Sox Win: One of Life's Big Adjustments 11.4.04

Doing More with Less 10.28.04

Not Ready to Bid Adieu 10.21.04

Lynch Calls On Congress To Implement
All 9/11 Commission Recommendations 10.14.04

Tommy, I Hardly Knew Ye 10.7.04

One Nation, Very Divided 9.16.04

Four Horsemen Ride Again on City Streets 9.09.04

Beginning Again at Saint William's 9.02.04

Rediscovering a Lost Sign of the Times 8.26.04

In Matters Presidential, Church Should Follow O'Malley's Lead 8.19.04
Boston Is Truly the Hub of the Non-Profit World 8.12.04

When Gentrification Moves In 8.05.04

Who Needs TV When We Have Our Own Dramas? 7.29.04

Will Kerry "Bring on Hart?" 7.22.04

John Kerry's Conundrum 7.15.04

Pure Politics Led to Legislature's Vote to Usurp Senate Seat 7.8.04

What Are We Waiting For? 6.24.04

Are Neighborhood Schools A Solution? 6.17.04

Team Spirit Needed to Win War 6.10.04

A June Sixth Dream 6.3.04

The Challenge: Rebuilding Trust 5.27.04

Loving Parents - Gay or Straight - Deserve Our Support 5.20.04

D.E.E.P. Students Debate a Hot Topic Among Children 5.13.04

It's the Little Things That Make Mothering So Tough, But Rewarding 5.6.04

Boston Must Prepare for Worst if LNG Tankers Are Targeted 4.29.04

Time to Reconsider the Rush to Close Thriving Parishes 4.22.04

Bulger's Name Belongs on Beautiful UMass Student Center 4.08.04

When a Soldier Dies 04.01.04

Church Closing Would Mark 'End' to Young Man's World 3.25.04

St. Mark's Is a Model for What
Our Church Aspires to Become
3.18.04

Parish Closure Recommendations Not Yet Final 3.4.04
Community Comment 2.26.04

Community Comment 2.19.04

Weighing the Decision on Gay Marriage 2.12.04

Sobering Thoughts on Our Nation's Direction 1.29.04

City Planning Hurt by BRA's Lack of Accountability 1.22.04

Bush's Immigration Reform Fails to Fix Broken System 1.15.04

Gay Neighbors Deserve Right to Marry 1.08.04

Operation 'Save-A-Spot' 1.02.04

Legislature, Not Bench, Should Have Final Say on Gay Marriage 12.18.03

Don't Rush Your Kids Through Childhood - 12.04.03

The Campaign That Changed Boston- 11.28.03

The Urban Gardener's Thanksgiving Day Schedule 11.20.03

Poor Strategy, Not 'Liberal Explosion,' Led to White's Demise 11.13.03

Why I Voted for the $87 Billion 11.06.03

New Kid on Campus 10.31.03

Moms Need a Mighty Wingman, Too 10.23.03

Dances With Bees 10.09.03

Don't Fight It When the Wiggles Come Calling 10.2.03

One Parent's Ongoing Siege of Teen's Drug Addiction 09.25.03

Keeping a Lid on the Snack Attacks 9.18.03

T's Fare Hike Out of Line 9.11.03

A Real Pickup Man -09.04.03

Flynn: '83 Mayoral Race Brought People Out - And the City Together- 8.21.03
A City That Works 8.14.03
Immigrant Dreams on Hold in Post-9-11 Backlash
Life At 22 Lonsdale Street 1940-1976- 7.31.03
City's Appointed "Impact Advisory Groups" Increase
Resident Input into Projects 7.24.03
Morrissey Lane Change Is Unfair, Arbitrary 7.17.03
Small Changes Have Big Impacts on Dot's Traffic Snarls 7.10.03
Sermons Off The Mount 7.2.03
Why I Bike to Work 6.19.03
A Vision for Edward Everett Square 6.12.03

Rivers' Ignorant Comments Prove HeIs Out of Touch 6.5.03


UMass-Boston and Dorchester: Where Do We Go from Here? 5.29.03

An Easy Equation: Senate Should Act Now to Save Home Health Care 05.22.03

Romney's Endless War is Aimed at Landing Him in the White House 05.15.03

Motherhood Transformation Brings Unexpected Joy- 5.08.03

Dorms Undermine UMass Boston's Original Mission-4.17.03

Easter: When Finished Isn't Finished 04.10.03

Weapon of Mass Distraction Opens Huge Hole for Profiteers 04.03.03

But Will It Make Us Safer? 3.20.03

Bulger Defends UMass Against Romney's "Attack on Higher Education" 3.13.03

Dorchester Hurts Itself with Divide Among Old, New Residents 3.6.03

UMass Chancellor Fails to Convince One Reader on Dorms 2.26.03

Money Woes Could Strangle Classroom Progress 2.20.03

The Faith Based Initiative as a Great Smoke Screen 2.13.03

Unilateral Strike Against Iraq Remains Unjustified 1.30.03 

Sen. Hart: Gathering Fiscal Storm Presents Challenges for Neighborhood 1.23.03

A Costly Move 1.16.03

Conley Lays Out Vision for District Attorney's Office 1.9.03

"Fairness schmairness" Press, Pundits Lose Balance on Bulger Story 12.12.02

Voice of the Vulnerable 12.5.02

Is President's Bill Really About Homeland Security? 11.21.01
Bush, Kennedy on War Prospects with Iraq 11.7.02

Putting Health of Murphy School Kids, Teachers First 10.31.02

Murphy, A Right, Honorable Gentleman 10.24.02

Dedicated Few Keep Democracy Alive As Media Tunes Out 9.26.02

The Skirmish 9.19.02

What's In a Name? Narrow-Minded Media Deepens Dot's Tricky Identity Crisis 9.12.02

Bush Administration Takes Ugly Anti-Immigrant Turn in Policy Towards Haitians 7.03.02

 

Back to the Reporter Home Page