All Contents © Copyright 2004, Boston Neighborhood News, Inc.
Community Comment
The News This Week from Dorchester
July 8, 2004
Pure Politics Led to Legislature's Vote to Usurp Senate Seat

To the Editor:

How pleased the Massachusetts Congressional delegation must be now - particularly the well-heeled Congressmen Ed Markey and Marty Meehan - that the State Senate and House of Representatives have decided to change the State Constitution and usurp the Constitution of The United States.

With our junior senato,r John Kerry, going to be the Democratic nominee in the fall against President Bush, the state legislature has gone and decided that the law which stipulates that the Governor of the Commonwealth be the person who shall name a replacement senator shall be stricken from our state's Constitution and they shall name a replacement.

It strikes me as odd that a state legislature can somehow disavow the 17th Amendment to our nation's constitution when the timing is right and political machinations and motivations mean more than the rule of law.

Let us take a look back for a second.

There was no call to restrict the governor's legitimate rights when Governor Foster Furculo appointed Benjamin Smith to take the senate position vacated by President-elect John F. Kennedy in 1960. Of course, Governor Furculo was a democrat as was Smith. Democrats also, conveniently, dominated both the State Senate and House of Representatives at the time.

Fast forward to today.

The House and the Senate are still both dominated by democrats but there is now a republican in the corner office.

Mitt Romney would like the same latitude that was given to Governor Furcolo in 1960. Why shouldn't he have it? He was elected by the populace of the commonwealth and justly entitled to the provisions that were set forth in our state's constitution as well as the nations constitution pertaining to the powers of the executives of the states.

What this comes down to is plain and simple partisan politics. The chambers on Beacon Hill are filled with salivating reps and senators who envision their chance to back a prospective candidate for the senate seat vacated by Kerry and potentially open up a higher political position for themselves.

This bill may come back in haunting forms unforeseen by the overly ambitious on "The Hill".

I present a hypothetical situation: The legislature names Congressman Stephen Lynch to fill the vacancy until a special election is held next year. Governor Romney then decides to run for the seat in the election. Romney wins (as polls presently indicate he would). Now we are left with a popular congressman without a job and a little known Lt. governor to run the state. Attorney General Tom Reilly then defeats Acting Governor Kerry Healy after wining the state's Democratic primary. Senator Ted Kennedy decides to call it quits after 40-plus years. Governor Reilly then is left with no decision to appoint a temporary replacement for the vacant seat.

Add to the above hypothetical proposition that Hell freezes over and both houses of the states legislature convert to Republican control.

Part of this fictional scenario is what now stares a popularly- elected Governor in the face. The Democrat-dominated legislature is unwilling to allow him to exercise his federally mandated authority (as is their right under the 17th amendment of the nations constitution).

This unprecedented step in our state's history smacks of such arrogance that it goes beyond partisan politics to the threshold of greed. If, as has been demonstrated in the past, the legislature isn't fond of the laws that govern them, they simply replace, ignore or manipulate them.

The Democrat Furculo had his right to appoint Smith to replace Kennedy. Romney should have been given the same benefit. Of course, all this could be a moot point come the first Tuesday in November.

George Greene

Harbor View St.

 Romney Shows True Colors with Anti-Immigrant Veto

To the Editor:

Nearly 30 years ago, I moved to Boston from my native Puerto Rico confident that I would find a model of educational excellence. Today, it saddens me to know that our Governor does not share this same vision and belief.

When Governor Romney vetoed a provision in the new state budget that would provide undocumented immigrant students with in-state tuition at Massachusetts' public colleges and universities, he unfairly stole hundreds of student's dreams. The governor takes great pride in his business background, so it is especially surprising to see that he is willing to pass-up a wonderful opportunity to foster economic vitality in Massachusetts.

The governor's anti-immigrant decision is a clear indicator that the he does not support equal opportunities for all residents of the Commonwealth. Regardless of their status, every high school student deserves the opportunity for higher education and a better future.

As a Latino elected official, I urge everyone to join me in fighting to ensure that Governor Romney does not continue to turn his back on the Latino and immigrant communities that make Massachusetts such a wonderful home.

Felix D. Arroyo

Boston City Councillor

 

Let Us Know What You Think!

What do you think? Why not write your own letter to the editor?
You can e-mail it to the Reporter newsroom at
letters@dotnews.com. The Reporter will only publish letters that are signed- and include a daytime phone number for verification.

 

Other recent commentaries from our neighbors:

Historical Curiosity Key to Dissecting Busing's Legacy 7.1.04

What Are We Waiting For? 6.24.04

Are Neighborhood Schools A Solution? 6.17.04

Team Spirit Needed to Win War 6.10.04

A June Sixth Dream 6.3.04

The Challenge: Rebuilding Trust 5.27.04

Loving Parents - Gay or Straight - Deserve Our Support 5.20.04

D.E.E.P. Students Debate a Hot Topic Among Children 5.13.04

It's the Little Things That Make Mothering So Tough, But Rewarding 5.6.04

Boston Must Prepare for Worst if LNG Tankers Are Targeted 4.29.04

Time to Reconsider the Rush to Close Thriving Parishes 4.22.04

Bulger's Name Belongs on Beautiful UMass Student Center 4.08.04

When a Soldier Dies 04.01.04

Church Closing Would Mark 'End' to Young Man's World 3.25.04

St. Mark's Is a Model for What
Our Church Aspires to Become
3.18.04

Parish Closure Recommendations Not Yet Final 3.4.04
Community Comment 2.26.04

Community Comment 2.19.04

Weighing the Decision on Gay Marriage 2.12.04

Sobering Thoughts on Our Nation's Direction 1.29.04

City Planning Hurt by BRA's Lack of Accountability 1.22.04

Bush's Immigration Reform Fails to Fix Broken System 1.15.04

Gay Neighbors Deserve Right to Marry 1.08.04

Operation 'Save-A-Spot' 1.02.04

Legislature, Not Bench, Should Have Final Say on Gay Marriage 12.18.03

Don't Rush Your Kids Through Childhood - 12.04.03

The Campaign That Changed Boston- 11.28.03

The Urban Gardener's Thanksgiving Day Schedule 11.20.03

Poor Strategy, Not 'Liberal Explosion,' Led to White's Demise 11.13.03

Why I Voted for the $87 Billion 11.06.03

New Kid on Campus 10.31.03

Moms Need a Mighty Wingman, Too 10.23.03

Dances With Bees 10.09.03

Don't Fight It When the Wiggles Come Calling 10.2.03

One Parent's Ongoing Siege of Teen's Drug Addiction 09.25.03

Keeping a Lid on the Snack Attacks 9.18.03

T's Fare Hike Out of Line 9.11.03

A Real Pickup Man -09.04.03

Flynn: '83 Mayoral Race Brought People Out - And the City Together- 8.21.03
A City That Works 8.14.03
Immigrant Dreams on Hold in Post-9-11 Backlash
Life At 22 Lonsdale Street 1940-1976- 7.31.03
City's Appointed "Impact Advisory Groups" Increase
Resident Input into Projects 7.24.03
Morrissey Lane Change Is Unfair, Arbitrary 7.17.03
Small Changes Have Big Impacts on Dot's Traffic Snarls 7.10.03
Sermons Off The Mount 7.2.03
Why I Bike to Work 6.19.03
A Vision for Edward Everett Square 6.12.03

Rivers' Ignorant Comments Prove HeIs Out of Touch 6.5.03


UMass-Boston and Dorchester: Where Do We Go from Here? 5.29.03

An Easy Equation: Senate Should Act Now to Save Home Health Care 05.22.03

Romney's Endless War is Aimed at Landing Him in the White House 05.15.03

Motherhood Transformation Brings Unexpected Joy- 5.08.03

Dorms Undermine UMass Boston's Original Mission-4.17.03

Easter: When Finished Isn't Finished 04.10.03

Weapon of Mass Distraction Opens Huge Hole for Profiteers 04.03.03

But Will It Make Us Safer? 3.20.03

Bulger Defends UMass Against Romney's "Attack on Higher Education" 3.13.03

Dorchester Hurts Itself with Divide Among Old, New Residents 3.6.03

UMass Chancellor Fails to Convince One Reader on Dorms 2.26.03

Money Woes Could Strangle Classroom Progress 2.20.03

The Faith Based Initiative as a Great Smoke Screen 2.13.03

Unilateral Strike Against Iraq Remains Unjustified 1.30.03 

Sen. Hart: Gathering Fiscal Storm Presents Challenges for Neighborhood 1.23.03

A Costly Move 1.16.03

Conley Lays Out Vision for District Attorney's Office 1.9.03

"Fairness schmairness" Press, Pundits Lose Balance on Bulger Story 12.12.02

Voice of the Vulnerable 12.5.02

Is President's Bill Really About Homeland Security? 11.21.01
Bush, Kennedy on War Prospects with Iraq 11.7.02

Putting Health of Murphy School Kids, Teachers First 10.31.02

Murphy, A Right, Honorable Gentleman 10.24.02

Dedicated Few Keep Democracy Alive As Media Tunes Out 9.26.02

The Skirmish 9.19.02

What's In a Name? Narrow-Minded Media Deepens Dot's Tricky Identity Crisis 9.12.02

Bush Administration Takes Ugly Anti-Immigrant Turn in Policy Towards Haitians 7.03.02

 

Back to the Reporter Home Page