All Contents © Copyright 2009, Boston Neighborhood News, Inc.
COMMUNITY COMMENT
March 19, 2009
Time to extend low-power radio service into cities

By Gloria Tristani

While the number of radio stations is growing, ownership is concentrated in fewer and fewer hands due to widespread media consolidation. This means today's radio often offers national playlists, syndicated programming and other piped-in content that threatens localism and the diversity of voices on the public airwaves.

When I was a member of the Federal Communications Commission (FCC), we established low power radio service in 2000 as a partial antidote to the negative effects of consolidation.

Low power radio (LPFM) makes new licenses available for nonprofit community organizations, churches, schools, and local governments.

Low power radio informs people about what is going on in their neighborhood or town; features local musicians and unique programming that reflects the local culture; and breaks from the same homogenized content that pushed radio listeners away.

When LPFM was created, it was intended to reach across the whole country from rural areas, to towns and cities; only excluding the most congested urban markets like New York and Los Angeles. These ambitions were halted when Congress placed unfair restrictions on the service due to existing broadcasters' exaggerated charges of interference. Congress directed the FCC to commission a study to investigate these claims.

In 2003, MITRE, a not-for-profit engineering and consulting firm, concluded its report and found, as the FCC had from the beginning, that this service would not cause harmful interference to existing radio stations. There are currently 800 existing LPFMs, but there is space for hundreds, potentially thousands more if Congress acts to remove the unnecessary restrictions placed on this service.

There are wonderful examples of LPFM in rural areas, playing an important part in bringing communities together. Clay, West Virginia, is an Appalachian coal town just north of Charleston and is home to one of the only local radio stations in Clay County. WYAP-LP is run by a handful of dedicated volunteers and the programming ranges from bluegrass music, to coverage of local sports games - and on Friday they only play West Virginia artists, giving a boost to many old-time musicians throughout the area.

WQRZ-LP in Bay St. Louis, Mississippi, brought national attention to the life-saving potential of LPFM when station manager Bryce Phillips waded through Katrina's flood water with a battery-pack strapped to his back in order to keep the station on air-broadcasting important emergency information-in the face of the deadly storm.

In the fields of Southwest Florida, the Coalition of Immokalee Workers immigrant farmworkers who pick tomatoes for the largest fast-food companies and suppliers in the country, have carved out their slice of the airwaves with Radio Conciencia. WCIW-LP carries programming in Spanish, Haitian Creole, and a number of indigenous Mayan languages spoken by the workers who are currently battling against sub-poverty wages and in extreme cases, modern-day slavery in Florida's tomato fields.

With the repeal of Congressional restrictions on LPFM, there could be more stations like WYAP, WQRZ, or WCIW not only in rural but also in suburban and urban America.

Low power radio promotes localism and diversity, not by limiting the rights of existing voices, but by adding new voices to the mix. Congress must enhance the statutory obligation to "encourage the larger and more effective use of radio in the public interest" by allowing this service to expand.

Bipartisan members of Congress have recently introduced a proposal to do so. President Obama's past support of similar legislation and his pledge to encourage diversity in the ownership of broadcast media and to promote the development of new media outlets for expression of diverse viewpoints demonstrate his commitment to expanding low power radio.

Moreover, the issue of expanding low power radio is ultimately a popular demand from community and civil rights groups, churches, schools, immigrants and average citizens.

Tristani is a former FCC Commissioner.

 

Vestiges of anti-Catholic cult sully state's Constitution with bigotry

By Jamie Gass

"The Irish are perhaps the only people in our history with the distinction of having a political party, the Know-Nothings, formed against them," wrote John F. Kennedy in his 1958 book - "A Nation of Immigrants." Today, few people realize the Massachusetts Constitution has two Know-Nothing-style amendments, which still thrust their mid-19th century bigotry into our world.

Massachusetts in the 1850s was a bustling, disjointed, and rapidly growing state. The Yankee commonwealth and its cities were undergoing seismic industrial and social transformations. New and powerful railroads, factories, telegraph lines, and banks ruled the day. The mass immigration of tens of thousands of souls fleeing the Irish famine fueled this mighty engine, which would drive the commonwealth's historic economic growth.

Despite making up one-quarter of the population in Boston and many other cities in Massachusetts, Irish immigrants were confronted by ethnic, religious and economic prejudice from urban Yankees. The Irish only sought what all immigrants look for in America: refuge from tyranny, religious freedom and jobs. Regrettably, wrote author Jack Beatty, "in the 1850s...(t)he grammar of Massachusetts politics was being laid down."

The American Party, or Know-Nothings, code-named "Sam," plotted its anti-immigrant rise in fraternal lodges one historian called, "cocoon(s) of secrecy." They assured clandestine party membership with peculiar handshakes and the password, "I know nothing." Charles Francis Adams, the anti-slavery statesman whose grandfather drafted the Massachusetts Constitution, rebuked "Sam," stating that the "essence of the secret obligations which bind these men together ... (was) productive of nothing but fraud, corruption, and treachery."

In 1854, the Know-Nothings rode a cunning platform of anti-Catholic nativism and progressive reforms to the largest electoral landslide in Bay State history. "Sam" had unmasked itself in the voting booths and swept every constitutional office in the state and won all but three legislative seats. Led by their governor, Henry J. Gardner, and a legislative super-majority, the Know-Nothings promulgated a flood of appallingly anti-constitutional laws designed to "Americanize America." Properly understood, Know-Nothingism was not so much a political movement, but an anti-Irish-Catholic cult.

More than 150 years later, Gov. Gardner's nativist "Anti-Aid" amendment, which prevents disbursement of state funds and local tax revenues to parochial schools, is an infamous legacy that still endures. In 1917, a revised "Anti-Aid" amendment was passed, and together these two constitutional sons of "Sam" continue to insult the integrity of both our educational system and state laws.

These Anti-Aid Amendments serve today as legal barriers to improving our children's education. The Know-Nothing amendments prevent more than 100,000 urban families in Massachusetts with children in chronically underperforming districts from receiving scholarship vouchers that would grant them greater school choice.

Removal of these amendments, which were conceived in prejudice, would help revitalize the urban educational landscape in Massachusetts. In essence, school funding from the state could follow the student, as it does in higher education across America, and all parents could choose from a wide variety of different private, parochial, public charter, vocational-technical, and religious school options for their children.

Critics of school choice frequently claim that having a choice would draw religion into the public domain. However, having individual parents, and not the state, utilizing scholarship vouchers to select the most appropriate schools for their children, respects the highest spirit of Thomas Jefferson's desire to keep "a wall of separation between church and state." By self-selecting their communities and schools, wealthy families have had these options available to them for decades. Currently, many poor children are walled off from the same educational opportunities.

Written by John Adams in 1780, the Massachusetts Constitution, the oldest written constitution in the world, just celebrated its 229th anniversary. Yet, today, Gov. Gardner's State House portrait hangs unsuspectingly next to the main entrance of the Massachusetts House of Representatives. Likewise, the Know-Nothings' bigoted amendments continue to reside cozily within our state's constitution.

This St. Patrick's month, we should honor the commonwealth's Irish heritage by appealing to America's best aspirations regarding religious freedom and schooling. We can accomplish this by lawfully expelling the Know-Nothings' anti-Irish-Catholic amendments from our realm. Then, once and for all, Massachusetts can finally declare to constitutionally-protected discrimination, "No, nay never no more."

Jamie Gass is the director of the Center for School Reform at Pioneer Institute, a Massachusetts public policy think tank.

 

Let Us Know What You Think!

What do you think? Why not write your own letter to the editor?
You can e-mail it to the Reporter newsroom at
letters@dotnews.com. The Reporter will only publish letters that are signed- and include a daytime phone number for verification.

 

Other recent commentaries from our neighbors:

It's time to do more with less 3.12.09

Kids advise President Obama on the job ahead 3.5.09

What the federal stimulus means for Boston 2.26.09

The Good News of Boston What to look for in a good leader 2.12.09

Catholic schools boost the nation's economy 2.5.09

Spirit of Obama on Castlegate 1.29.09

Martin Hanley, who has died at 91, 'embraced the Boston community' 1.15.09

Obama presidency = renewed hope 1.8.09

Lehane's latest novel paints the White, Black, and Red of Boston's history 1.1.09

Suspect: white, male, white beard, button nose, driving eight tiny reindeer 12.24.08

One way to weather the financial storm is to get to know what your banker is up to 12.18.08

One way to weather the financial storm is to get to know what your banker is up to 12.11.08

Volunteer elves make Christmas season brighter in Dot 12.4.08

Police Details: Mend them, don't end them 11.27.08

The Urban Gardener'sThanksgiving Day Schedule 11.20.08

Like Lincoln, Obama holds promise of greatness 11.13.08

Former rival: St. Fleur has been a disappointment 11.6.08

This is not just another election 10.30.08

Remembering the incredible election of '83 10.23.08

'Keep your pigs out of my corn': Town government by selectmen 10.26.08

Smart 'urban planning' begins at home 10.9.08

Lupo captured the voices of Boston's neighborhoods over five decades 10.2.08

Just asking: Where was the bailout for the families on Hendry Street? 9.25.08

The debate on question 2 9.18.08

Community organizers help make democracy work in vital ways 9.11.08

Not sold yet on the Internet presidency 9.04.08

Starting the school year off on a fun note 08.28.08

Came for the Olympics, stayed for the passion 8.21.08

A scandal on the fairways 8.14.08

Let's talk about this elephant 8.7.08

You couldn't make this stuff up 7.24.08

Something's fishy up in Beverly 7.17.08

Irishman to the rescue 7.03.08

Letter: Kerry failed to impress first-time delegate 6.26.08

The poor need more urgent attention 6.12.08

You down with OFD? Yeah, you know me! 5.29.08

My friend Ann Marie surely made

the most of her all-too-brief journey 5.22.08

Night to remember a giant of Port Norfolk 5.15.08

Frank offers Rx for housing relief 5.1.08

It's that time of year: Help clean your neighborhood

this weekend 4.24.08

Newspaper gatekeepers: a vanishing breed? 4.17.08

Remembering when New Kids grabbed our hearts 4.3.08

State Supreme Court allows firearm evidence despite "unlawful" search 3.27.08

Quietly, another St. Pat's breakfast helps the needy 3.20.08

Let's deal with our real scandals 3.13.08

City job could be a click away 3.6.08

Second thoughts from the foxhole 2.28.08

Asking the Right Questions 2.14.08


Football gods frowned on our hubris 2.7.08

Obama vs. Clinton : Two views on the choice 1.31.08


Moms of victims, perpetrators work together 1.10.08

My aunts, my Dorchester roots: A case of love and connection 12.27.07

Project D.E.E.P. kids give gifts to the world 12.20.07

Pastors: Coverage of 2010 plans was "negative" 12.13.07

A sensible approach to marijuana policy 12.6.07

Of bullies, buddies, and boyos: a day with 'EEI 11.29.07

The Urban Gardener's Thanksgiving Day Schedule 11.21.07

Letters to the Editor 11.8.07

Local reaction mixed to Gone Baby, Gone 11.1.07

Going it alone 10.18.07

Kevin Fitzgerald built bridges far beyond Mission Hill 10.11.07
Showdown looms on property tax codes
with Shirley Kressel and Sam Tyler 10.4.07


Council candidate defends position on fire hearings, regrets offense taken- Letters 9.27.07

Ad distorted Feeney's position on fire response- Letters 9.20.07

Commission, lawmakers led the way on beaches 9.4.07

Waging world peace, one step at a time 8.23.07

Dorchester Park in need of oversight for safety reasons 8.16.07

Let's value our parks 8.7.07

A neighbor's plight puts things in perspective 8.2.07

Accountability and fuzzy math in the electoral realm 7.26.07

Store 24 hours, location a bad mix 7.19.07

Dot Park fun day shows neighborhood at its best 7.12.07

Caddying at the old Wollaston Golf Club:
a summertime job with staying power 7.5.07

Remembering the kids from 'the Hill' 6.28.07

Best cops study human nature 6.21.07

Invest in what we have now 5.17.07

Thanks to all for a spiffy job 5.10.07

More work needed at Shawmut station 5.03.07

State should finish Port Norfolk park site 4.26.07

MBTA indeed negligent on Hillsdale Street 4.19.07

Expansion crucial to future of UMass-Boston 4.12.07

9/11: A strategic victory for terror 4.5.07

Exception taken to story on council candidates forum 3.29.07

Lynch: Push Iraq on responsibility 3.22.07

City's middle class is under siege;
residency law should be kept in place 3.15.07

Don't turn the lights out just yet 3.8.07

Newspaper did right thing in spotlighting church plans 3.1.07

Headline, article were irresponsible 2.22.07

Dot's 'ethnic ballet' complicated by un-affordable housing 2.8.07

Violence, lack of progress feed concern
in Bowdoin-Geneva neighborhood 1.25.07

Up or down vote is only legal course for lawmakers 1.11.07

Mass distractions,mass destruction 1.4.07

Old Reporter columnist, friend checks in for the holidays 12.14.06

Recently preserved open space has 'wild' past 12.07.06

The Urban Gardener's Thanksgiving Day Schedule 11.09.06

Residency requirement needs to be enforced, not revoked 11.02.06

Letters in support of Kerry Healey, Deval Patrick 10.26.06

Make Cuba 51 8.10.06

Family: Son's deat was not caused by drug overdose 7.27.06
Tenean cookout left mess, showed
disrespect for neighborhood 7.13.06

New police e-lert system raises privacy concerns 7.6.06

After frightening fall, three year-old teaches her
family about heart and courage 6.22.06

Board of Trade scholarship winners celebratebest of neighborhood 6.15.06

Who's on First? What is First? 6.1.06

Dorchester Girls in Citizen Schools Speak Out on Violence 5.25.06

On Freeland St., neighbors feel disrespected 5.18.06

Civic groups: We want Armstrong back in charge at C-11 5.11.06

Command of police districts needs to stay connected to the community 5.4.06

Underage drinking a silent epidemic 4.27.06

Melville Ave. homeowner 'victim of own decisions,' not neighbors

Disputed 99 Melville Avenue home about family, not zoning 4.13.06

Crime statistics &endash; garbage in, garbage out 4.06.06

Ashmont Station name should include Peabody Square3.30.06

In Niger, suffering most cruel to newest arrivals 3.23.06

Process violated in Columbia-Savin Hill 3.16.06

Fr. Kierce was a true Dorchester 'character' 3.9.06

Gaming would generate much-needed revenue for the Commonwealth 3.2.06

Disagree with soldier on war, but respect his service 2.23.06

Undocumented Irish packed Florian Hall
for immigration reform rally 2.16.06

Revisionist history polluting young minds 2.09.06

Teach the truth about American history in Mass schools 2.2.06

Dorchester needs health care reform 1.26.06

Legislature does its part to protect witnesses 1.19.06

'Brutal' days followed successful election 1.12.06

Christmas night, outside South Bay... 1.05.06

Logic lacking in Christmas message of Menino, Reporter 12.29.05

Duck the malls or yule feel sorry 12.22.05

Rash of shootings shows it is time to rethink prevention techniques 12.15.05

Mattapan man writes from Iraq 12.8.05

Booth swings and misses in assessment of Ali 12.1.05

Dear, would you pass the Salt Junk? 11.23.05

The Urban Gardener's Thanksgiving Day Schedule 11.17.05

Rome decides that legalisms trump facts in Saint William's case 11.10.05

Lucchino vs. Epstein: Media stew boils over 11.03.05

Hijacking government 10.27.05

Disturbing trends in community policing posture 10.20.05

Houston was a legal freedom fighter 10.13.05

For one Dot voter, 'unfair' dog law holds sway 10.6.05

Clam Point complaints reveal city's inadequate planning 9.29.05

Firefighters 'manipulated truth' in Grove Hall memorial issue 9.22.05

Declaration of dependence 9.15.05

Increasing fairness in Boston Latin School admissions 9.1.05

Art connecting lives right here in Adams Corner 8.25.05

The human eyes of God 8.18.05

City's preservation policies should go further 8.11.05

"I Wonder What Jesus Would Have Done" 8.4.05

Promising Young Nigerian Man's Death a Tragedy for All 7.28.05

Here's to You 7.21.05

Thanks All Around for Spring Triumphs in Field's Corner 7.14.05

A Time to Speak Out about Violence, Prevention 7.7.05

Time to End Complacency and Wage Renewed Campaign against Crime

Questions Remain About Park Fate 6.16.05

The Truth Be Told 6.9.05

Civic Group Did Its Job in Cedar Grove 6.2.05

Wilson the Right President to Lead UMass 5.26.05

John Beresford's Murder Raises Questions for our Community 5.19.05

It Really Burns Him 5.12.05

The Truth about Our 'Fancestors' 5.05.05

Writer Should Have Offered More ID 4.28.05

Drumming Up Support to Restore a Civil War Memorial 4.21.05

Motley Part of the Problem, Not Solution 4.14.05

Essay Winners Reflect on Dorchester Day 4.7.05

In Remembrance of Ricky Dever 3.31.05

Not a Good Day for the Good Guys 3.24.05

Democracy Tolls for Whom? 3.17.05

Bush Budget Puts the Lie to 'Compassion' 3.10.05

Charter Schools Give Boston Public Much-Needed Competition 2.24.05

Ocean Zoning Needed to Protect Off-Shore Waters 2.17.05

DotWell - An Extended View of Health Care 2.03.05

How to Tell If You're Really an Irish Pol 1.27.05

You Gotta Have Friends 1.13.05

When Never Means Maybe 1.06.05

Putting the Hurt over Merged Parish on Hold for Holidays 12.16.04

Choir Article Was One-Sided 12.09.04

License to Ill 12.02.04

Article Failed to Give Balanced Development Picture 11.25.04

Romney Gets Out-Hustled on Homeland Security Issues 11.18.04

Being John Kerry 11.11.04

Sox Win: One of Life's Big Adjustments 11.4.04

Doing More with Less 10.28.04

Not Ready to Bid Adieu 10.21.04

Lynch Calls On Congress To Implement
All 9/11 Commission Recommendations 10.14.04

Tommy, I Hardly Knew Ye 10.7.04

One Nation, Very Divided 9.16.04

Four Horsemen Ride Again on City Streets 9.09.04

Beginning Again at Saint William's 9.02.04

Rediscovering a Lost Sign of the Times 8.26.04

In Matters Presidential, Church Should Follow O'Malley's Lead 8.19.04
Boston Is Truly the Hub of the Non-Profit World 8.12.04

When Gentrification Moves In 8.05.04

Who Needs TV When We Have Our Own Dramas? 7.29.04

Will Kerry "Bring on Hart?" 7.22.04

John Kerry's Conundrum 7.15.04

Pure Politics Led to Legislature's Vote to Usurp Senate Seat 7.8.04

What Are We Waiting For? 6.24.04

Are Neighborhood Schools A Solution? 6.17.04

Team Spirit Needed to Win War 6.10.04

A June Sixth Dream 6.3.04

The Challenge: Rebuilding Trust 5.27.04

Loving Parents - Gay or Straight - Deserve Our Support 5.20.04

D.E.E.P. Students Debate a Hot Topic Among Children 5.13.04

It's the Little Things That Make Mothering So Tough, But Rewarding 5.6.04

Boston Must Prepare for Worst if LNG Tankers Are Targeted 4.29.04

Time to Reconsider the Rush to Close Thriving Parishes 4.22.04

Bulger's Name Belongs on Beautiful UMass Student Center 4.08.04

When a Soldier Dies 04.01.04

Church Closing Would Mark 'End' to Young Man's World 3.25.04

St. Mark's Is a Model for What
Our Church Aspires to Become
3.18.04

Parish Closure Recommendations Not Yet Final 3.4.04
Community Comment 2.26.04

Community Comment 2.19.04

Weighing the Decision on Gay Marriage 2.12.04

Sobering Thoughts on Our Nation's Direction 1.29.04

City Planning Hurt by BRA's Lack of Accountability 1.22.04

Bush's Immigration Reform Fails to Fix Broken System 1.15.04

Gay Neighbors Deserve Right to Marry 1.08.04

Operation 'Save-A-Spot' 1.02.04

Legislature, Not Bench, Should Have Final Say on Gay Marriage 12.18.03

Don't Rush Your Kids Through Childhood - 12.04.03

The Campaign That Changed Boston- 11.28.03

The Urban Gardener's Thanksgiving Day Schedule 11.20.03

Poor Strategy, Not 'Liberal Explosion,' Led to White's Demise 11.13.03

Why I Voted for the $87 Billion 11.06.03

New Kid on Campus 10.31.03

Moms Need a Mighty Wingman, Too 10.23.03

Dances With Bees 10.09.03

Don't Fight It When the Wiggles Come Calling 10.2.03

One Parent's Ongoing Siege of Teen's Drug Addiction 09.25.03

Keeping a Lid on the Snack Attacks 9.18.03

T's Fare Hike Out of Line 9.11.03

A Real Pickup Man -09.04.03

Flynn: '83 Mayoral Race Brought People Out - And the City Together- 8.21.03
A City That Works 8.14.03
Immigrant Dreams on Hold in Post-9-11 Backlash
Life At 22 Lonsdale Street 1940-1976- 7.31.03
City's Appointed "Impact Advisory Groups" Increase
Resident Input into Projects 7.24.03
Morrissey Lane Change Is Unfair, Arbitrary 7.17.03
Small Changes Have Big Impacts on Dot's Traffic Snarls 7.10.03
Sermons Off The Mount 7.2.03
Why I Bike to Work 6.19.03
A Vision for Edward Everett Square 6.12.03

Rivers' Ignorant Comments Prove HeIs Out of Touch 6.5.03


UMass-Boston and Dorchester: Where Do We Go from Here? 5.29.03

An Easy Equation: Senate Should Act Now to Save Home Health Care 05.22.03

Romney's Endless War is Aimed at Landing Him in the White House 05.15.03

Motherhood Transformation Brings Unexpected Joy- 5.08.03

Dorms Undermine UMass Boston's Original Mission-4.17.03

Easter: When Finished Isn't Finished 04.10.03

Weapon of Mass Distraction Opens Huge Hole for Profiteers 04.03.03

But Will It Make Us Safer? 3.20.03

Bulger Defends UMass Against Romney's "Attack on Higher Education" 3.13.03

Dorchester Hurts Itself with Divide Among Old, New Residents 3.6.03

UMass Chancellor Fails to Convince One Reader on Dorms 2.26.03

Money Woes Could Strangle Classroom Progress 2.20.03

The Faith Based Initiative as a Great Smoke Screen 2.13.03

Unilateral Strike Against Iraq Remains Unjustified 1.30.03 

Sen. Hart: Gathering Fiscal Storm Presents Challenges for Neighborhood 1.23.03

A Costly Move 1.16.03

Conley Lays Out Vision for District Attorney's Office 1.9.03

"Fairness schmairness" Press, Pundits Lose Balance on Bulger Story 12.12.02

Voice of the Vulnerable 12.5.02

Is President's Bill Really About Homeland Security? 11.21.01
Bush, Kennedy on War Prospects with Iraq 11.7.02

Putting Health of Murphy School Kids, Teachers First 10.31.02

Murphy, A Right, Honorable Gentleman 10.24.02

Dedicated Few Keep Democracy Alive As Media Tunes Out 9.26.02

The Skirmish 9.19.02

What's In a Name? Narrow-Minded Media Deepens Dot's Tricky Identity Crisis 9.12.02

Bush Administration Takes Ugly Anti-Immigrant Turn in Policy Towards Haitians 7.03.02

 

Back to the Reporter Home Page