|
By Lewis Finfer
Have you ever seen the photo from 1976 of a white high
school student who appears to be using a flag pole with an
American flag on it to attack a black man in a suit? This
was the searing incident for our city that came to symbolize
Boston's racial troubles.
A book has just been published that thoughtfully examines
how this photo was taken, what the principal participants
thought then and now, and how an illustration can be a kind
of archetype symbol of a whole set of events in history. The
book is titled "The Soiling of Old Glory: the Story of the
Photograph that Shocked America" and it is by Louis P.
Masur, a professor from Trinity College in Hartford. "The
Soiling of Old Glory" was the title put on this photo that
won a Pulitzer Prize for then-Boston Herald photographer
Stanley Forman. Forman since has become a news cameraman for
WCVB Channel 5 TV.
If you lived here during those years, the events then
have shaped much of how you feel about race and class
issues. If you didn't live here then, you still have been
impacted by how those times still affect the Boston Public
Schools today and the attitudes of other residents who live
around you.
On April 5, 1976, white high school students at South
Boston and Charlestown High School were staging one of their
periodic protests against the federal desegregation court
order by walking out of school and going on a protest march.
This time they went to City Hall and after they were
received there by anti-busing City Councillor Louise Day
Hicks, they headed out of City Hall to the corridor that
runs to Washington Street.
Around the corner and inadvertently into the middle of
the demonstrators came Ted Landsmark, a black man dressed in
a suit who was on his way to a meeting at City Hall. Some of
the demonstrators beat and kicked him. One demonstrator
wielding the flag took a swipe at him. Jimmy Kelly, an
ardent anti-busing leader and later a city councillor, was
part of the demonstration, but tried to get Landsmark away
from the students to end the fight.
Forman was a resourceful news photographer and he had the
luck to be in the right place at the right time, as most
great photographers do,to record this incident. Forman's
photo appeared on the front page of the Boston Herald next
to a story headlined, "Youths beat black lawyer at City
Hall." The next day, the photo ran in newspapers around the
country. It cemented an image of Boston as a city of racial
divisions that could disintegrate into hatred.
Landsmark held a press conference two days after the
incident with his face heavily bandaged from the broken nose
and cuts he had suffered. At the press conference, he said,
"that he was struck in the face with an American flag in
front of City Hall not far from Faneuil Hall (which was
called the Cradle of Liberty as a site of events of the
American Revolution), at a location not far from the site
'where Crispus Attucks [an African-American killed in
the Boston Massacre incident that led up to the American
Revolution] got his.'" He went on to say "racism is the
apparent direct cause of Monday's unprovoked attack on me...
Safety is not the issue. Busing is not the issue. The issue
involves the participation of citizens of color in all
levels of government."
Perhaps even more remarkable was what this man who was
the victim of this terrible racial incident then said about
the question of class. "The chances of any of the kids who
attacked me ending up on a major corporate board are as slim
as any black kid ending up on a board," he said.
At a recent forum on the book, I asked Ted Landsmark how
he &emdash;the victim of a terrible racial incident&emdash;
could speak at the same time about the role of class.
Landsmark said, "I grew up in an East Harlem housing project
with a single-parent mother in a neighborhood that was in
the process of changing from Italian to Latino. We were all
working class people living together. I knew that."
"It was easy for me to later work for Mayor Ray Flynn
[who opposed busing, but was a progressive populist on
economic issues] from South Boston because his dad was a
longshoreman and mine was a subway conductor. I was
fortunate to get to go to a year of prep school, to Yale,
and to Yale Law School. I had extraordinary luck. But there
for the grace of God, the lives of the kids who beat me
could have been mine. "I couldn't hate those kids. I knew
them [their kind of life]. I could have been them,
they could have been me."
The story of the "flag kid" named Joseph Rakes, who
lunged at Ted Landsmark, was a poignant one too. He was
angered by busing. He said, "You can't have half your
friends...they took half the boys and girls I grew up with
and said, 'You're going to school on the other side of
town.'"
Like me, Landsmark recognizes that many young people in
Boston regard these events as distant history. "You might as
well be talking to them about Lincoln freeing the slaves as
talk to them about busing and how it tore neighborhoods
apart," he says.
We are a very different city today than in 1976. Where
people of color once feared to walk, they now may live in
significant numbers. Our school system is no longer 60
percent white, but is now 85 percent kids of color. City
elections cannot be won solely by getting votes from working
class white neighborhoods as was true back then. Diversity
and multiculturalism are values held up across many aspects
of life now. Yet, if and when an issue seems to divide us,
let's learn from our past and work very hard to find the
common ground.
Lewis Finfer is a Dorchester resident and director of the
Dorchester-based Massachusetts Communities Action
Network.
Let Us Know What
You Think!
What do you think? Why not write
your own letter to the editor?
You can e-mail it to the Reporter newsroom at
letters@dotnews.com.
The Reporter will only publish letters that are signed- and
include a daytime phone number for verification.
Other recent commentaries from our
neighbors:
A vivid reminder of
Boston's not-so-distant past 4.10.08
Remembering when
New Kids grabbed our hearts 4.3.08
State
Supreme Court allows firearm evidence despite "unlawful"
search
3.27.08
Quietly,
another St. Pat's breakfast helps the
needy
3.20.08
Let's
deal with our real scandals
3.13.08
City job
could be a click away 3.6.08
Second
thoughts from the foxhole
2.28.08
Asking
the Right Questions 2.14.08
Football
gods frowned on our hubris
2.7.08
Obama
vs. Clinton : Two views on the choice
1.31.08
Moms
of victims, perpetrators work together
1.10.08
My
aunts, my Dorchester roots: A case of love and connection
12.27.07
Project
D.E.E.P. kids give gifts to the world 12.20.07
Pastors:
Coverage of 2010 plans was "negative" 12.13.07
A
sensible approach to marijuana policy 12.6.07
Of
bullies, buddies, and boyos: a day with 'EEI
11.29.07
The
Urban Gardener's Thanksgiving Day Schedule
11.21.07
Letters
to the Editor 11.8.07
Local
reaction mixed to Gone Baby, Gone
11.1.07
Going
it alone 10.18.07
Kevin
Fitzgerald built bridges far beyond Mission Hill
10.11.07
Showdown
looms on property tax codes
with Shirley Kressel and Sam Tyler
10.4.07
Council
candidate defends position on fire hearings, regrets offense
taken- Letters 9.27.07
Ad
distorted Feeney's position on fire response- Letters
9.20.07
Commission,
lawmakers led the way on beaches
9.4.07
Waging
world peace, one step at a time
8.23.07
Dorchester
Park in need of oversight for safety reasons
8.16.07
Let's
value our parks 8.7.07
A
neighbor's plight puts things in perspective 8.2.07
Accountability
and fuzzy math in the electoral realm
7.26.07
Store
24 hours, location a bad mix
7.19.07
Dot
Park fun day shows neighborhood at its best
7.12.07
Caddying
at the old Wollaston Golf Club:
a summertime job with staying power
7.5.07
Remembering
the kids from 'the Hill' 6.28.07
Best
cops study human nature
6.21.07
Invest
in what we have now 5.17.07
Thanks
to all for a spiffy job 5.10.07
More
work needed at Shawmut station 5.03.07
State
should finish Port Norfolk park site
4.26.07
MBTA
indeed negligent on Hillsdale Street
4.19.07
Expansion
crucial to future of UMass-Boston 4.12.07
9/11:
A strategic victory for terror
4.5.07
Exception
taken to story on council candidates forum
3.29.07
Lynch:
Push Iraq on responsibility
3.22.07
City's
middle class is under siege;
residency law should be kept in place
3.15.07
Don't
turn the lights out just yet 3.8.07
Newspaper
did right thing in spotlighting church plans
3.1.07
Headline,
article were irresponsible 2.22.07
Dot's
'ethnic ballet' complicated by un-affordable housing
2.8.07
Violence,
lack of progress feed concern
in Bowdoin-Geneva neighborhood 1.25.07
Up
or down vote is only legal course for lawmakers
1.11.07
Mass
distractions,mass destruction 1.4.07
Old
Reporter columnist, friend checks in for the holidays
12.14.06
Recently
preserved open space has 'wild' past
12.07.06
The
Urban Gardener's Thanksgiving Day Schedule
11.09.06
Residency
requirement needs to be enforced, not revoked
11.02.06
Letters
in support of Kerry Healey, Deval Patrick
10.26.06
Make
Cuba 51 8.10.06
Family:
Son's deat was not caused by drug overdose
7.27.06
Tenean
cookout left mess, showed
disrespect for neighborhood 7.13.06
New
police e-lert system raises privacy concerns
7.6.06
After
frightening fall, three year-old teaches her
family about heart and courage 6.22.06
Board
of Trade scholarship winners celebratebest of neighborhood
6.15.06
Who's
on First? What is First?
6.1.06
Dorchester
Girls in Citizen Schools Speak Out on Violence
5.25.06
On
Freeland St., neighbors feel disrespected
5.18.06
Civic
groups: We want Armstrong back in charge at C-11 5.11.06
Command
of police districts needs to stay connected to the community
5.4.06
Underage
drinking a silent epidemic 4.27.06
Melville
Ave. homeowner 'victim of own decisions,' not
neighbors
Disputed
99 Melville Avenue home about family, not zoning
4.13.06
Crime
statistics &endash; garbage in, garbage out
4.06.06
Ashmont
Station name should include Peabody
Square3.30.06
In
Niger, suffering most cruel to newest arrivals
3.23.06
Process
violated in Columbia-Savin Hill 3.16.06
Fr.
Kierce was a true Dorchester 'character'
3.9.06
Gaming
would generate much-needed revenue for the Commonwealth
3.2.06
Disagree
with soldier on war, but respect his service
2.23.06
Undocumented
Irish packed Florian Hall
for immigration reform rally 2.16.06
Revisionist
history polluting young minds 2.09.06
Teach
the truth about American history in Mass schools
2.2.06
Dorchester
needs health care reform 1.26.06
Legislature
does its part to protect witnesses
1.19.06
'Brutal'
days followed successful election 1.12.06
Christmas
night, outside South Bay... 1.05.06
Logic
lacking in Christmas message of Menino, Reporter
12.29.05
Duck
the malls or yule feel sorry 12.22.05
Rash
of shootings shows it is time to rethink prevention
techniques 12.15.05
Mattapan
man writes from Iraq
12.8.05
Booth
swings and misses in assessment of Ali
12.1.05
Dear,
would you pass the Salt Junk? 11.23.05
The
Urban Gardener's Thanksgiving Day Schedule
11.17.05
Rome
decides that legalisms trump facts in Saint William's case
11.10.05
Lucchino
vs. Epstein: Media stew boils over
11.03.05
Hijacking
government 10.27.05
Disturbing
trends in community policing posture
10.20.05
Houston
was a legal freedom fighter 10.13.05
For
one Dot voter, 'unfair' dog law holds sway
10.6.05
Clam
Point complaints reveal city's inadequate planning
9.29.05
Firefighters
'manipulated truth' in Grove Hall memorial issue
9.22.05
Declaration
of dependence 9.15.05
Increasing
fairness in Boston Latin School admissions
9.1.05
Art
connecting lives right here in Adams Corner
8.25.05
The
human eyes of God 8.18.05
City's
preservation policies should go further
8.11.05
"I
Wonder What Jesus Would Have Done"
8.4.05
Promising
Young Nigerian Man's Death a Tragedy for All
7.28.05
Here's
to You 7.21.05
Thanks
All Around for Spring Triumphs in Field's Corner
7.14.05
A
Time to Speak Out about Violence, Prevention
7.7.05
Time
to End Complacency and Wage Renewed Campaign against
Crime
Questions
Remain About Park Fate 6.16.05
The
Truth Be Told 6.9.05
Civic
Group Did Its Job in Cedar Grove 6.2.05
Wilson
the Right President to Lead UMass 5.26.05
John
Beresford's Murder Raises Questions for our Community
5.19.05
It
Really Burns Him 5.12.05
The
Truth about Our 'Fancestors' 5.05.05
Writer
Should Have Offered More ID 4.28.05
Drumming
Up Support to Restore a Civil War Memorial
4.21.05
Motley
Part of the Problem, Not Solution 4.14.05
Essay
Winners Reflect on Dorchester Day 4.7.05
In
Remembrance of Ricky Dever
3.31.05
Not
a Good Day for the Good Guys 3.24.05
Democracy
Tolls for Whom? 3.17.05
Bush
Budget Puts the Lie to 'Compassion'
3.10.05
Charter
Schools Give Boston Public Much-Needed Competition
2.24.05
Ocean
Zoning Needed to Protect Off-Shore Waters
2.17.05
DotWell
- An Extended View of Health Care 2.03.05
How
to Tell If You're Really an Irish Pol
1.27.05
You
Gotta Have Friends 1.13.05
When
Never Means Maybe 1.06.05
Putting
the Hurt over Merged Parish on Hold for Holidays
12.16.04
Choir
Article Was One-Sided 12.09.04
License
to Ill 12.02.04
Article
Failed to Give Balanced Development Picture
11.25.04
Romney
Gets Out-Hustled on Homeland Security Issues
11.18.04
Being
John Kerry 11.11.04
Sox
Win: One of Life's Big Adjustments
11.4.04
Doing
More with Less 10.28.04
Not
Ready to Bid Adieu 10.21.04
Lynch
Calls On Congress To Implement
All 9/11 Commission Recommendations
10.14.04
Tommy,
I Hardly Knew Ye 10.7.04
One
Nation, Very Divided 9.16.04
Four
Horsemen Ride Again on City Streets
9.09.04
Beginning
Again at Saint William's
9.02.04
Rediscovering
a Lost Sign of the Times
8.26.04
In
Matters Presidential, Church Should Follow O'Malley's Lead
8.19.04
Boston
Is Truly the Hub of the Non-Profit World
8.12.04
When
Gentrification Moves In 8.05.04
Who
Needs TV When We Have Our Own Dramas?
7.29.04
Will
Kerry "Bring on Hart?" 7.22.04
John
Kerry's Conundrum 7.15.04
Pure
Politics Led to Legislature's Vote to Usurp Senate Seat
7.8.04
What
Are We Waiting For? 6.24.04
Are
Neighborhood Schools A Solution? 6.17.04
Team
Spirit Needed to Win War 6.10.04
A
June Sixth Dream 6.3.04
The
Challenge: Rebuilding Trust 5.27.04
Loving
Parents - Gay or Straight - Deserve Our Support
5.20.04
D.E.E.P.
Students Debate a Hot Topic Among Children
5.13.04
It's
the Little Things That Make Mothering So Tough, But
Rewarding 5.6.04
Boston
Must Prepare for Worst if LNG Tankers Are Targeted
4.29.04
Time
to Reconsider the Rush to Close Thriving Parishes 4.22.04
Bulger's
Name Belongs on Beautiful UMass Student
Center
4.08.04
When
a Soldier Dies 04.01.04
Church
Closing Would Mark 'End' to Young Man's World
3.25.04
St.
Mark's Is a Model for What
Our Church Aspires to Become
3.18.04
Parish
Closure Recommendations Not Yet
Final
3.4.04
Community
Comment 2.26.04
Community
Comment 2.19.04
Weighing
the Decision on Gay
Marriage
2.12.04
Sobering
Thoughts on Our Nation's
Direction
1.29.04
City
Planning Hurt by BRA's Lack of Accountability
1.22.04
Bush's
Immigration Reform Fails to Fix Broken System
1.15.04
Gay
Neighbors Deserve Right to Marry 1.08.04
Operation
'Save-A-Spot' 1.02.04
Legislature,
Not Bench, Should Have Final Say on Gay Marriage
12.18.03
Don't
Rush Your Kids Through Childhood -
12.04.03
The
Campaign That Changed Boston-
11.28.03
The
Urban Gardener's Thanksgiving Day Schedule
11.20.03
Poor
Strategy, Not 'Liberal Explosion,' Led to White's Demise
11.13.03
Why
I Voted for the $87 Billion 11.06.03
New
Kid on Campus
10.31.03
Moms
Need a Mighty Wingman, Too
10.23.03
Dances
With Bees
10.09.03
Don't
Fight It When the Wiggles Come Calling 10.2.03
One
Parent's Ongoing Siege of Teen's Drug Addiction
09.25.03
Keeping
a Lid on the Snack Attacks
9.18.03
T's
Fare Hike Out of Line
9.11.03
A
Real Pickup Man -09.04.03
Flynn:
'83 Mayoral Race Brought People Out - And the City Together-
8.21.03
A
City That Works 8.14.03
Immigrant
Dreams on Hold in Post-9-11
Backlash
Life
At 22 Lonsdale Street 1940-1976-
7.31.03
City's
Appointed "Impact Advisory Groups" Increase
Resident
Input into Projects 7.24.03
Morrissey
Lane Change Is Unfair, Arbitrary
7.17.03
Small
Changes Have Big Impacts on Dot's Traffic Snarls
7.10.03
Sermons
Off The Mount
7.2.03
Why
I Bike to Work
6.19.03
A
Vision for Edward Everett Square 6.12.03
Rivers'
Ignorant Comments Prove HeIs Out of Touch
6.5.03
UMass-Boston
and Dorchester: Where Do We Go from Here?
5.29.03
An
Easy Equation: Senate Should Act Now to Save Home Health
Care
05.22.03
Romney's
Endless War is Aimed at Landing Him in the White House
05.15.03
Motherhood
Transformation Brings Unexpected Joy-
5.08.03
Dorms
Undermine UMass Boston's Original
Mission-4.17.03
Easter:
When Finished Isn't Finished 04.10.03
Weapon
of Mass Distraction Opens Huge Hole for Profiteers
04.03.03
But
Will It Make Us Safer? 3.20.03
Bulger
Defends UMass Against Romney's "Attack on Higher Education"
3.13.03
Dorchester
Hurts Itself with Divide Among Old, New Residents
3.6.03
UMass
Chancellor Fails to Convince One Reader on Dorms
2.26.03
Money
Woes Could Strangle Classroom Progress
2.20.03
The
Faith Based Initiative as a Great Smoke Screen
2.13.03
Unilateral
Strike Against Iraq Remains Unjustified
1.30.03
Sen.
Hart: Gathering Fiscal Storm Presents Challenges for
Neighborhood 1.23.03
A
Costly Move 1.16.03
Conley
Lays Out Vision for District Attorney's Office
1.9.03
"Fairness
schmairness"
Press,
Pundits Lose Balance on Bulger
Story
12.12.02
Voice
of the Vulnerable 12.5.02
Is
President's Bill Really About Homeland Security?
11.21.01
Bush,
Kennedy on War Prospects with Iraq
11.7.02
Putting
Health of Murphy School Kids, Teachers
First
10.31.02
Murphy,
A Right, Honorable Gentleman 10.24.02
Dedicated
Few Keep Democracy Alive As Media Tunes Out
9.26.02
The
Skirmish 9.19.02
What's
In a Name?
Narrow-Minded Media
Deepens Dot's Tricky Identity Crisis
9.12.02
Bush
Administration Takes Ugly Anti-Immigrant Turn in Policy
Towards Haitians 7.03.02
Back
to the Reporter Home Page
|