All Contents © Copyright 2003 Boston Neighborhood News, Inc.
WWW.dotnews.com
Editorial Points for This Week
The News This Week from Dorchester at dotnews.com
July 17, 2003
Legislators Make Right Call in Bilingual Ed Reform

Dorchester State Rep. Marie St. Fleur was working late in her State House office on Monday night. The Dorchester legislator was sending out handwritten notes to her colleagues in the House, thanking them for their support in overturning a gubernatorial veto of a portion of the so-called immersion law.

"I support immersion, I absolutely do support immersion," the Haiti-born St. Fleur said. "I don't support transitional bilingual assistance at all. Do what happened to me: Mainstream me, put me right in there with my English-speaking friends. But if a child is having difficulty, somebody should help them. Give them some assistance with English, give that child ESL, tutoring or whatever they need."

On Monday, her legislative colleagues overrode a veto by Bain and Company's Mitt Romney and modified the law to allow so-called two-way programs for kindergarten children. Currently, St. Fleur says, only about 2000 children statewide are in such programs.

"It allows the children to be immersed in two languages, English and a second language. It is proven that it works," she said. "It allows 100 percent of the kids to be bilingual."

Romney vowed this week to mount political opponents to legislators who voted in favor of the override and it was a threat which many legislators took seriously.

"I am really disappointed this governor would choose to be involved in the politics of polarization," St. Fleur says. "It took a lot of courage to vote for the override and I am proud of my colleagues."

-Ed Forry

Legislature Clarifies Bilingual Reform Measures

According to Rep. St. Fleur's office, here is what the Legislature's override did and did not do this week:

•The Legislature did not make major changes to the Unz petition, Question 2.

• The Legislature adopted clarifying amendments that would not change the intent of the legislation.

•SECTION 209 allows kindergarten English language learners to be educated in either sheltered English immersion or English language mainstreamed classes with support in English language acquisition. Question 2 as adopted would force students into segregated classrooms for one year with other students speaking a variety of languages other than English. Only the teacher would know how to speak English. This section would, instead, allow these kindergarten youngsters the option of being educated in regular education classes with their English speaking peers. In this way, they could learn the language by speaking it with native English speakers. At this young age, learning a second language is much easier than it would be for older students.

• SECTION 210. Currently the Unz petition allows children 10 years of age or older to waive into two-way/immersion bilingual programs. This section allows students of any age to take part in two-way/immersion bilingual programs.

• SECTION 212 includes language from the Bilingual Education Reform Law approved by the Legislature last summer which requires districts to teach English learners to the same academic standards and curriculum frameworks as all other students. This accountability language was stricken by Question 2. It is crucial to student success that this accountability language be reinstated. It would also require school districts to issue report cards and progress reports that grade English acquisition for English language learners.

 

Recent Editorials

Hot Weather Musings 7.10.03

The Daunting Challenge That Awaits Archbishop O'Malley 7.2.03

Where is all this traffic coming from? 6.26.03

A Milton Miracle? 6.19.03 

Taking Pride in Our Own Yards and Sidewalks 6.12.03

What Was Tom Reily Thinking? 6.5.03

A Time to Celebrate Dorchester's Proud History 5.29.03

A Wise Investment in Our City's Subway Stations 05.22.03

We Need More Independent Media, Not Less 05.15.03

Bleak Outlook for Summer Jobs for Kids 05.08.03

A Sensible Framework for Dialogue on Dorms at UMass

Celebrating the Many Contributions of Non-Profit Dorchester 04.24.03

BI-Deaconess Chooses Fenway Over City's Neediest 04.17.03

Finally, Reaping the Benefits of the Big Dig 04.10.03

Leaning on Each Other in a Time of War 04.03.03

A Noble Way to Lend Our Support 03.27.03

Don't Blame Me...I Voted for the Democrat 03.20.03

Romney's Vision Out of Synch with City's Needs  

Media Snipers Should Holster Their Weapons and Get Back to Business 2.26.03

A Touch of Home 'Over There' 2.20.03

The JFK Library & Museum Remains a Great Local Resource 2.13.03

Anti-War Measure Worthy of Council's Attention 2.6.03

Beth Israel-Deaconess Medical Center Should Make a More Graceful Exit from Columbia-Savin Hill 1.30.03

Ted Kennedy Captures King's Legacy at the Right Time 1.23.03

Our Legislators Deserve Their Modest Pay Raise 1.16.03

Heroic Deeds and Tragic Failures:The Duality of Cardinal Law 12.12.02

Attacks on Bulger Leave Questions About Press,
Abuse of Power 12.5.02

A First Rate Appointment by Commissioner Evans-11.14.02

Hart, Jenkins, St. Fleur and O'Brien Will Get Our Vote 10.31.02
Time to Check Rental Price Gouging 10.24.02

Broadcast TV Ads Distort Elections 10.17.02

Spectre of Drug Abuse Growing in Neighborhood 10.10.02

Feeney Does a Tough Job and Does It Well 10.3.02

'Average' Turnout Not Good Enough 9.26.02

Romney- Healey Ticket Short on Substance 9.19.02

A Wise Investment in Our Transit System 9.12.02

Lazy Days of Summer Give Way to Political Prime Time 9.5.02

An Impressive New 3 Decker in Fields Corner 8.29.02

Many Questions Bubble As Heat Wave Subsides 8.22.02

A New Home for City's Treasures 8.15.02

Time for Real Plan on Columbia Point 8.8.02

Residency Question Sparks Dialogue Among Reporter Readers 8.1.02

'Trickle Down' Economics Back with a Vengeance 7.25.02

Williams Saga Among the Saddest This Summer 7.18.02

City Must Gird Itself for Renewed War on Crime 7.11.02
The Declaration of Independence: A Transcription 7.03.02
Speaker Acted for Constituents, Not Himself, Along Neponset 6.27.02

Quietly, New Group of American Heroes Emerges 6.20.02
Next Week's Zoning Hearing An Important One 6.13.02
Reality TV... Too Close To Home 6.06.02
Dot Day Parade a Time to Celebrate Common Bonds 5.30.02
Tough Questions Await City's Zoning Board 5.23.02
Law, Church Losing Battle for Public Opinion by Default 5.16.02
Neighbors Pull Together to Support Lawsuit Victims-5.9.02
Time for Community to Stand Up for Neighbors in Lower Mills Lawsuit 5.02.02
Our Parishes, Schools Likely to Bear Brunt of Scandal's Fallout 4.25.02
An Intriguing Solution to Supermarket Standoff in Lower Mills 4.18.02
Church Leaders Must Face Justice for Criminal Acts
A Victory for Everyone in Uphams Corner 4.04.02
ABCD Still Going Strong After 40 Years 03.28.02
A Homegrown Solution to Mitt's Star Power 03.21.02
Fatality Highlights Hazards of Columbia Rd. 03.14.02
Diversity Compromised by Democrats' Caucus 3.07.02

Final Act Needed in Lower Mills Supermarket War 2.28.02
Developers Need to Do the Right Thing in Lower Mills
Brigham's is Gone, Now What's to Become of Us? 2.14.02
Pats Set Tone for a Great Sports Year
Dot Residency Not Only Quality Sought in Senator 1.31.02
Joe Fahey's Enduring Legacy 1.24.02
Demand for Rental Housing Ebbs and Flows 1.17.02
Repairs to Begin on Lower Mills Bridge 1.10.02
Another's Man Poison
Finneran's Experience, Leadership Is the Right Fit for a Trying Time
Will Stop & Shop Repeat Mistakes Made in Lower Mills?
Map Continues Ugly Tradition of Dividing Dorchester 12.6.01
Time to Shed Biases and Consider Dot's True Identity-11.29.01
BostonVote Leads Way Towards Election Reform-11.23.01
Honoring Heroes in Our Midst
Paul Christian Seems Right Choice for Fire Commissioner

Finally, A Dorchester Senate Seat-11.8.01
Hennigan Stands Out for At-Large Council-11.1.01
Hypocrisy Finds Home in Newton-10.25.01
Focus Now Turns to All-Important Redistricting Effort
Great Hall Breakfast Sends Right Message-10.11.01
'GBH Reporter Misreads Meaning of Flag, Professionalism-10.4.01
We're Willing to Pay for Trained, Reliable Security-9.27.01
 Day of Terror, Months of Anxiety- 9.20.01
The Kind of Person The Country Needs Right Now-9.13.01
New Parking Challenges at UMass-8.30.01
Proof That Crimes Aren't Just City Problem-8.9.01
Silly Season Starts Early in Council Election-8.2.01
Future Facility a More Fitting Symbol for UMass-7.26.01
Speaker Opens Windows On Redistricting Process
Time to Celebrate Our Waterfront 7.12.01
Koalas Will Spend Summer in Our Backyard 6.21.01
"We Do It in Dorchester" 6.7.01
Advice to Max Kennedy: Just Say "No" 5.24.01  
Why Is City Hall Dividing Dorchester? 5.17.01
Saluting a Hero Among Us- Dr. Tom Durant-4.26.01
Let's Give Gov. Swift a Fair Shot- 4.12.01
Dot Dig May Need A Traffic Summit-3.29.01
Clarifying Some Confusion Over Boundaries- 3.15.01

 

Back to Reporter Home Page