|
Race relations continue to
be a "third rail" issue in politics. A full generation after
the forced busing/ school desegregation battles of the
1970s, there remain some strong feelings over the actions
that took place in that sad era, and there is new evidence
that the psychic wounds from those times have yet to
heal.
Last week, this newspaper
published a letter from a resident aimed at Senator Jack
Hart. This "open letter" took the able young senator to task
for his attendance at the funeral of Mrs. Louise Day Hicks,
a former school committee member and member of Congress who
passed last month. Senator Hart attended the woman's South
Boston funeral, and made the mistake of making comments to a
Boston Globe reporter that seemed to the letter writer to be
racially insensitive.
The full history of Boston's
racial battles of the last generation have yet to be
written. For those of us who lived through those unhappy
events, it is difficult to separate the emotion of the
battles from the validity of the problem.
There is no doubt there was
separateness in Boston schools, and that black children were
treated unjustly and illegally by the school board. The
fundamental problem with the court remedy imposed by the
late Judge W. Arthur Garrity was that the court remedy had
the effect of punishing the children, rather than the
wrong-doers. It would have been so much better if Garrity
had punished the school committee members, and sought a more
equitable solution to achieving a quality education for the
school children. Instead, the court order had the effect of
setting neighborhoods against each other, and the school
children in the public schools became the pawns in those
battles.
The role Mrs. Hicks had in the
battles during the 1970s is largely one that took place in
the background. Mrs. Hicks had run and lost for Mayor to
Kevin White in 1967; in 1970, while still on the school
committee, she was elected to a term in the Congress, and
left her role in city politics behind. In 1972, she was
defeated by J. Joseph Moakley, and by the time the busing
order came about, Mrs. Hicks no longer held public
office.
But by then, in the racial
debates, she had become a negative symbol in the media and,
as a result, in the public's mind. When the busing order
came down, she was portrayed, along with other busing foes,
as an unreconstructed racist.
In her later years, Mrs. Hicks
returned to the private practice of law, and she spent many
hours working for a Dorchester-based bank. We saw her
several times in the neighborhood, and when we asked if she
would be willing to sit for an interview, she
declined.
Persons with a long view of those
struggles lament that there was so little leadership shown
in ameliorating the negative effects of the busing court
order. It was not a good time, for anyone. And the long term
effect of the the Garrity order are still subject to
debate.
As for the actions of Senator
Hart, it needs to be said he is a good and decent man, and a
caring politician. To paint him with the brush of
insensitivity as a result of his attendance at the funeral
is unfair. Christians believe that to bury the dead is a
corporal act of mercy.
As for the political era which
became symbolized by Mrs. Hicks and her campaign utterance,
"You know where I stand," let us agree that those days are
behind us. What was needed then, as now is not just
tolerance, but more Christian compassion and mercy.
-Ed Forry
Recent
Editorials
A
Mixed Shopping Bag 11.06.03
Council
Weigh-Ins
10.31.03
Venting
on The Day After
10.23.03
Something
in the Dirty Water
10.16.03
Dot's
Newest Bank Shows Great Promise for Growth and Community
Investment-
10.02.03
Memo
to Greenbush Foes: Get Over It
09.25.03
Increasingly,
Drugs Are Stealing Our Kids
09.18.03
A
Public Servant of the Highest Order
09.11.03
School,
Civic Season Begins in Earnest 09.04.03
Forgotten
Boston 08.21.03
Celebrities
Mock Our Republic
08.4.03
O'Malley
Will Lead from Within
08.07.03
Menino
Has Proved the Skeptics Wrong 07.31.03
A
Grand New Store for Dorchester
7.24.03
Legislators
Make Right Call in Bilingual Ed Reform
7.17.03
Hot
Weather Musings 7.10.03
The
Daunting Challenge That Awaits Archbishop O'Malley
7.2.03
Where
is all this traffic coming
from?
6.26.03
A
Milton Miracle?
6.19.03
Taking
Pride in Our Own Yards and Sidewalks
6.12.03
What
Was Tom Reily Thinking? 6.5.03
A
Time to Celebrate Dorchester's Proud
History
5.29.03
A
Wise Investment in Our City's Subway Stations
05.22.03
We
Need More Independent Media, Not Less
05.15.03
Bleak
Outlook for Summer Jobs for Kids
05.08.03
A
Sensible Framework for Dialogue on Dorms at
UMass
Celebrating
the Many Contributions of Non-Profit Dorchester
04.24.03
BI-Deaconess
Chooses Fenway Over City's Neediest
04.17.03
Finally,
Reaping the Benefits of the Big Dig
04.10.03
Leaning
on Each Other in a Time of War 04.03.03
A
Noble Way to Lend Our Support
03.27.03
Don't
Blame Me...I Voted for the
Democrat
03.20.03
Romney's
Vision Out of Synch with City's Needs
Media
Snipers Should Holster Their Weapons and Get Back to
Business 2.26.03
A
Touch of Home 'Over There' 2.20.03
The
JFK Library & Museum Remains a Great Local Resource
2.13.03
Anti-War
Measure Worthy of Council's
Attention
2.6.03
Beth
Israel-Deaconess Medical Center Should Make a More Graceful
Exit from Columbia-Savin Hill 1.30.03
Ted
Kennedy Captures King's Legacy at the Right Time
1.23.03
Our
Legislators Deserve Their Modest Pay Raise
1.16.03
Heroic
Deeds and Tragic Failures:The Duality of Cardinal Law
12.12.02
Attacks
on Bulger Leave Questions About Press,
Abuse of Power 12.5.02
A
First Rate Appointment by Commissioner
Evans-11.14.02
Hart,
Jenkins, St. Fleur and O'Brien Will Get Our Vote
10.31.02
Time
to Check Rental Price Gouging 10.24.02
Broadcast
TV Ads Distort Elections
10.17.02
Spectre
of Drug Abuse Growing in
Neighborhood
10.10.02
Feeney
Does a Tough Job and Does It Well 10.3.02
'Average'
Turnout Not Good Enough 9.26.02
Romney-
Healey Ticket Short on Substance 9.19.02
A
Wise Investment in Our Transit System
9.12.02
Lazy
Days of Summer Give Way to Political Prime Time
9.5.02
An
Impressive New 3 Decker in Fields Corner
8.29.02
Many
Questions Bubble As Heat Wave Subsides
8.22.02
A
New Home for City's Treasures 8.15.02
Time
for Real Plan on Columbia Point 8.8.02
Residency
Question Sparks Dialogue Among Reporter
Readers
8.1.02
'Trickle
Down' Economics Back with a
Vengeance
7.25.02
Williams
Saga Among the Saddest This Summer
7.18.02
City
Must Gird Itself for Renewed War on Crime
7.11.02
The
Declaration of Independence: A Transcription
7.03.02
Speaker
Acted for Constituents, Not Himself, Along Neponset
6.27.02
Quietly,
New Group of American Heroes Emerges
6.20.02
Next
Week's Zoning Hearing An Important One
6.13.02
Reality
TV... Too Close To Home
6.06.02
Dot
Day Parade a Time to Celebrate Common Bonds
5.30.02
Tough
Questions Await City's Zoning Board
5.23.02
Law,
Church Losing Battle for Public Opinion by Default
5.16.02
Neighbors
Pull Together to Support Lawsuit
Victims-5.9.02
Time
for Community to Stand Up for Neighbors in Lower Mills
Lawsuit 5.02.02
Our
Parishes, Schools Likely to Bear Brunt of Scandal's Fallout
4.25.02
An
Intriguing Solution to Supermarket Standoff in Lower Mills
4.18.02
Church
Leaders Must Face Justice for Criminal
Acts
A
Victory for Everyone in Uphams Corner
4.04.02
ABCD
Still Going Strong After 40 Years
03.28.02
A
Homegrown Solution to Mitt's Star Power
03.21.02
Fatality
Highlights Hazards of Columbia Rd.
03.14.02
Diversity
Compromised by Democrats' Caucus 3.07.02
Final
Act Needed in Lower Mills Supermarket War
2.28.02
Developers
Need to Do the Right Thing in Lower
Mills
Brigham's
is Gone, Now What's to Become of Us? 2.14.02
Pats
Set Tone for a Great Sports Year
Dot
Residency Not Only Quality Sought in Senator
1.31.02
Joe
Fahey's Enduring Legacy 1.24.02
Demand
for Rental Housing Ebbs and Flows
1.17.02
Repairs
to Begin on Lower Mills Bridge
1.10.02
Another's
Man Poison
Finneran's
Experience, Leadership Is the Right Fit for a Trying
Time
Will
Stop & Shop Repeat Mistakes Made in Lower
Mills?
Map
Continues Ugly Tradition of Dividing Dorchester
12.6.01
Time
to Shed Biases and Consider Dot's True
Identity-11.29.01
BostonVote
Leads Way Towards Election
Reform-11.23.01
Honoring
Heroes in Our Midst
Paul Christian Seems Right Choice for Fire
Commissioner
Finally,
A Dorchester Senate Seat-11.8.01
Hennigan
Stands Out for At-Large
Council-11.1.01
Hypocrisy
Finds Home in Newton-10.25.01
Focus
Now Turns to All-Important Redistricting Effort
Great
Hall Breakfast Sends Right
Message-10.11.01
'GBH
Reporter Misreads Meaning of Flag,
Professionalism-10.4.01
We're
Willing to Pay for Trained, Reliable
Security-9.27.01
Day
of Terror, Months of Anxiety-
9.20.01
The
Kind of Person The Country Needs Right Now-9.13.01
New
Parking Challenges at
UMass-8.30.01
Proof
That Crimes Aren't Just City
Problem-8.9.01
Silly
Season Starts Early in Council
Election-8.2.01
Future
Facility a More Fitting Symbol for
UMass-7.26.01
Speaker
Opens Windows On Redistricting
Process
Time
to Celebrate Our Waterfront
7.12.01
Koalas
Will Spend Summer in Our Backyard
6.21.01
"We
Do It in Dorchester"
6.7.01
Advice
to Max Kennedy: Just Say "No"
5.24.01
Why
Is City Hall Dividing Dorchester?
5.17.01
Saluting
a Hero Among Us- Dr. Tom
Durant-4.26.01
Let's
Give Gov. Swift a Fair Shot-
4.12.01
Dot
Dig May Need A Traffic
Summit-3.29.01
Clarifying
Some Confusion Over Boundaries-
3.15.01
Back
to Reporter Home Page
|