All Contents © Copyright 2004 Boston Neighborhood News, Inc.
WWW.dotnews.com
Editorial Points for This Week
The News This Week from Dorchester at dotnews.com
May 6, 2004
Finneran Will Survive Latest Witchhunt Against Him

Joe Bergantino was on the hunt.

Speaker Tom Finneran joined Mrs.Teresa Heinz, Senate President Robert Travaglini and several others at a press event last month at the Mattapan Health Center, to announce a plan to help seniors and working class people afford the high costs of prescription drugs. Finneran's staff had arranged for the press event at this vital not-for-profit health care facility on Blue Hill Avenue, just outside of Mattapan Square - in the middle of the Speaker's legislative district. The cost of health care is a compelling issue in this neighborhood and Finneran is no stranger at this health center.

But Bergantino, an investigative reporter with the television station once known as WBZ-TV, was there to stalk Finneran. Word had leaked that the Speaker was being questioned about the veracity of his statements in a civil court case about redistricting legislative districts. Speaker Finneran has come under attack by political foes and some media people, on the basis that Finneran is somehow racist in his politics. The TV newsman was there to play "gotcha" on the Mattapan rep.

As Finneran began to leave, a TV cameraman began to record, and Mr. Beragantino stuck a microphone in front of him. "No comment for you, Joe - now and forever," Finneran said. The cameraman was told to keep recording as the Speaker climbed into the passenger seat of a car. It would be great television, showing the speaker avoiding this questioner and driving off.

But there was a glitch - as the video continued to roll, the car remained at the sidewalk, and then Dr. Azzie Young, the health center's director, moved into the shot to give her thanks to the Speaker. Finneran got out of the car, Dr. Young hugged him, and the two talked for several moments.

The cameraman stopped the shoot: evidently, the pictures of this black woman and her white state rep, obviously good friends, did not fit the storyline. That night, only the video sequence showing Finneran declining to comment was broadcast. It was sensational TV, but it was grossly unfair and terribly unbalanced.

This vignette is evidence of a common occurrence in Tom Finneran's current public life. Our state rep finds himself in the crosshairs of any number of attacks - from political foes, from media assassins, from members of the public who know him only from the caricatures of him that appear in the news.

Finneran has sought help from an aggressive defense attorney, and the man's first effort this week goes a long way towards deflecting the critical onslaught.

Attorney Richard Egbert on Monday referred to a footnote in the recent court decision which said in part, "Although Speaker Finneran denied any involvement in the redistricting process, the circumstantial evidence strongly suggests the opposite conclusion."

Egbert said, "The media, and others, have quoted this footnote in repeated efforts to attack the credibility of Speaker Finneran. It is now time to correct the record... we strongly believe that the court's language... is simply wrong. Without a doubt, it is entirely contrary to the evidence that was presented in court.

"Indeed, Speaker Finneran never denied any involvement in the redistricting process," Egbert said. "Rather... (he) acknowledged his role." Transcripts from the court proceedings clearly reveal that Finneran acknowledged taking an active role in the process.

It is to be hoped that the Finneran response this week will bring an end to the attacks on this man. It is a fond hope, but it's not likely to be the reality. It has happened before, and will again, that people in public life are placed under the glare of adverse and unwelcomed publicity. The media's lust for a story is fed by the public's appetite for scandal, no matter the high quality of the person.

It deserves to be said here: Tom Finneran is a good man, a wonderful neighbor, and a great legislator. He is and always has been an outstanding advocate for the issues that matter to the residents of his district.

Are people in the district all of one mind with him on every issue? Certainly not. But does the Speaker deserve the mindless attacks that seem to be coming from every quarter? Certainly not.

For years, his foes have posited the canard that he is re-elected each time because people fear him. It needs to be said here that Finneran is well-liked and even loved in all parts of his district. Among his neighbors and constituents - those who know him best - we think we're fortunate to have him as our state rep.

-Ed Forry

 

Recent Editorials
Bill Should Get Speaker's Backing 4.29.04

To Father, with Love 4.22.04

On Iraq, Little Comfort from President's Words 4.15.04

Changes Ahead at Caritas? 4.8.04

Two Men Do Dorchester Proud 4.1.04

Globe Swings into Action to Torpedo UMass Pick 3.25.04

A Great Chance to Cross-Pollinate at Flower Show 3.18.04

Getting to the Polls on Tuesday 2.26.04

A Village in Need of Civic Activity 2.19.04

Elected Officials Deserve Respect for Taking a Stand 2.12.04

Dunford the Best Choice for Commisisoner 2.5.04

A Cop's Cop 1.29.04

Radio's Resident 'Dope-Slapper' Burns Listeners with Deception 1.22.04

A Church of Change 1.15.04

No Truth, Few Consequences 1.08.04

Looking to Recapture That Political Magic in 2004 1.02.04

Who's Watching Our Imperial Governor? 12.04.03

Time to Right Wrongs on Gay Marriage 11.28.03

Busings Brusies Still Deep and Unhealed 11.13.03

A Mixed Shopping Bag 11.06.03

Council Weigh-Ins 10.31.03

Venting on The Day After 10.23.03

Something in the Dirty Water 10.16.03

Dot's Newest Bank Shows Great Promise for Growth and Community Investment- 10.02.03
Memo to Greenbush Foes: Get Over It 09.25.03
Increasingly, Drugs Are Stealing Our Kids 09.18.03
A Public Servant of the Highest Order 09.11.03
School, Civic Season Begins in Earnest 09.04.03
Forgotten Boston 08.21.03
Celebrities Mock Our Republic 08.4.03
O'Malley Will Lead from Within 08.07.03
Menino Has Proved the Skeptics Wrong 07.31.03
A Grand New Store for Dorchester 7.24.03
Legislators Make Right Call in Bilingual Ed Reform 7.17.03
Hot Weather Musings 7.10.03
The Daunting Challenge That Awaits Archbishop O'Malley 7.2.03
Where is all this traffic coming from? 6.26.03
A Milton Miracle? 6.19.03 
Taking Pride in Our Own Yards and Sidewalks 6.12.03
What Was Tom Reily Thinking? 6.5.03
A Time to Celebrate Dorchester's Proud History 5.29.03
A Wise Investment in Our City's Subway Stations 05.22.03
We Need More Independent Media, Not Less 05.15.03
Bleak Outlook for Summer Jobs for Kids 05.08.03
A Sensible Framework for Dialogue on Dorms at UMass

Celebrating the Many Contributions of Non-Profit Dorchester 04.24.03

BI-Deaconess Chooses Fenway Over City's Neediest 04.17.03

Finally, Reaping the Benefits of the Big Dig 04.10.03

Leaning on Each Other in a Time of War 04.03.03

A Noble Way to Lend Our Support 03.27.03

Don't Blame Me...I Voted for the Democrat 03.20.03

Romney's Vision Out of Synch with City's Needs  

Media Snipers Should Holster Their Weapons and Get Back to Business 2.26.03

A Touch of Home 'Over There' 2.20.03

The JFK Library & Museum Remains a Great Local Resource 2.13.03

Anti-War Measure Worthy of Council's Attention 2.6.03

Beth Israel-Deaconess Medical Center Should Make a More Graceful Exit from Columbia-Savin Hill 1.30.03

Ted Kennedy Captures King's Legacy at the Right Time 1.23.03

Our Legislators Deserve Their Modest Pay Raise 1.16.03

Heroic Deeds and Tragic Failures:The Duality of Cardinal Law 12.12.02

Attacks on Bulger Leave Questions About Press,
Abuse of Power 12.5.02

A First Rate Appointment by Commissioner Evans-11.14.02

Hart, Jenkins, St. Fleur and O'Brien Will Get Our Vote 10.31.02
Time to Check Rental Price Gouging 10.24.02

Broadcast TV Ads Distort Elections 10.17.02

Spectre of Drug Abuse Growing in Neighborhood 10.10.02

Feeney Does a Tough Job and Does It Well 10.3.02

'Average' Turnout Not Good Enough 9.26.02

Romney- Healey Ticket Short on Substance 9.19.02

A Wise Investment in Our Transit System 9.12.02

Lazy Days of Summer Give Way to Political Prime Time 9.5.02

An Impressive New 3 Decker in Fields Corner 8.29.02

Many Questions Bubble As Heat Wave Subsides 8.22.02

A New Home for City's Treasures 8.15.02

Time for Real Plan on Columbia Point 8.8.02

Residency Question Sparks Dialogue Among Reporter Readers 8.1.02

'Trickle Down' Economics Back with a Vengeance 7.25.02

Williams Saga Among the Saddest This Summer 7.18.02

City Must Gird Itself for Renewed War on Crime 7.11.02
The Declaration of Independence: A Transcription 7.03.02
Speaker Acted for Constituents, Not Himself, Along Neponset 6.27.02

Quietly, New Group of American Heroes Emerges 6.20.02
Next Week's Zoning Hearing An Important One 6.13.02
Reality TV... Too Close To Home 6.06.02
Dot Day Parade a Time to Celebrate Common Bonds 5.30.02
Tough Questions Await City's Zoning Board 5.23.02
Law, Church Losing Battle for Public Opinion by Default 5.16.02
Neighbors Pull Together to Support Lawsuit Victims-5.9.02
Time for Community to Stand Up for Neighbors in Lower Mills Lawsuit 5.02.02
Our Parishes, Schools Likely to Bear Brunt of Scandal's Fallout 4.25.02
An Intriguing Solution to Supermarket Standoff in Lower Mills 4.18.02
Church Leaders Must Face Justice for Criminal Acts
A Victory for Everyone in Uphams Corner 4.04.02
ABCD Still Going Strong After 40 Years 03.28.02
A Homegrown Solution to Mitt's Star Power 03.21.02
Fatality Highlights Hazards of Columbia Rd. 03.14.02
Diversity Compromised by Democrats' Caucus 3.07.02

Final Act Needed in Lower Mills Supermarket War 2.28.02
Developers Need to Do the Right Thing in Lower Mills
Brigham's is Gone, Now What's to Become of Us? 2.14.02
Pats Set Tone for a Great Sports Year
Dot Residency Not Only Quality Sought in Senator 1.31.02
Joe Fahey's Enduring Legacy 1.24.02
Demand for Rental Housing Ebbs and Flows 1.17.02
Repairs to Begin on Lower Mills Bridge 1.10.02
Another's Man Poison
Finneran's Experience, Leadership Is the Right Fit for a Trying Time
Will Stop & Shop Repeat Mistakes Made in Lower Mills?
Map Continues Ugly Tradition of Dividing Dorchester 12.6.01
Time to Shed Biases and Consider Dot's True Identity-11.29.01
BostonVote Leads Way Towards Election Reform-11.23.01
Honoring Heroes in Our Midst
Paul Christian Seems Right Choice for Fire Commissioner

Finally, A Dorchester Senate Seat-11.8.01
Hennigan Stands Out for At-Large Council-11.1.01
Hypocrisy Finds Home in Newton-10.25.01
Focus Now Turns to All-Important Redistricting Effort
Great Hall Breakfast Sends Right Message-10.11.01
'GBH Reporter Misreads Meaning of Flag, Professionalism-10.4.01
We're Willing to Pay for Trained, Reliable Security-9.27.01
 Day of Terror, Months of Anxiety- 9.20.01
The Kind of Person The Country Needs Right Now-9.13.01
New Parking Challenges at UMass-8.30.01
Proof That Crimes Aren't Just City Problem-8.9.01
Silly Season Starts Early in Council Election-8.2.01
Future Facility a More Fitting Symbol for UMass-7.26.01
Speaker Opens Windows On Redistricting Process
Time to Celebrate Our Waterfront 7.12.01
Koalas Will Spend Summer in Our Backyard 6.21.01
"We Do It in Dorchester" 6.7.01
Advice to Max Kennedy: Just Say "No" 5.24.01  
Why Is City Hall Dividing Dorchester? 5.17.01
Saluting a Hero Among Us- Dr. Tom Durant-4.26.01
Let's Give Gov. Swift a Fair Shot- 4.12.01
Dot Dig May Need A Traffic Summit-3.29.01
Clarifying Some Confusion Over Boundaries- 3.15.01

 

Back to Reporter Home Page